In addition to their ecological role, salmon also provide provisioning, cultural, and supporting services to local communities. Addressing and resolving problems of fit are therefore critical to the sustainable management of natural resources and the well-being of the diverse cultures and communities they support. These kinds of mismatches can be difficult to respond to and, if unaddressed, can degrade SESs either through disruption of function, inefficiencies in the system, and (or) simplification through the loss of important system components ( Cumming et al. For example, fishing quotas based on the utilitarian concept of maximum sustainable yield can often be mismatched with the natural dynamics of fish populations they exploit which can undermine the resilience of the biological system and result in depleted fisheries ( Acheson and Wilson 1996). When the scales of social organization and environmental variation are mismatched, problems can arise in either the institutions that are responsible for management and (or) the ecological systems that are being managed ( Young 2002 Cumming et al. Institutions often fail to match the diversity of local settings and the complexity of the ecosystems with which they interact ( Holling and Meffe 1996 Young 2002 Wilson 2006). Mismatches between institutions and social–ecological systems (SESs), often termed institutional mismatches or problems of fit, are a major sustainability challenge in natural resource management ( Young 2002 Cash et al. While these findings are based on the Skeena River watershed, they may be generalizable to other salmon SESs in which mismatches between social and ecological processes and institutions exist. I argue that improving social–ecological fit in salmon SESs will require new or revitalized forms of environmental governance that consciously fit the underlying social–ecological dynamics. This case study suggests that mismatches are threatening salmon sustainability and negatively affecting Indigenous People’s rights, livelihoods, and approaches to resource management and stewardship. Utilizing Canadian federal environmental assessments as a proxy for colonial environmental governance institutions, I describe the common causes and consequences of mismatches between institutions and salmon SESs. ![]() Here, I use the theoretical concept of fit to examine institutional alignment in a large-scale Pacific salmon SES, the Skeena River watershed in British Columbia, Canada. ![]() This is particularly true for complex SESs, such as on the Pacific Coast of North America, where salmon drive interactions across multiple environments, jurisdictions, and scales. However, while mismatches are often cited in the literature as a major challenge, empirical evidence of mismatches and their consequences is limited. ![]() Mismatches between institutions and social–ecological systems (SESs) are one of the foremost challenges in natural resource management.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |